Philo Beers House

In the mid-1860s, Philo Beers owned all of what is known as block 2, which extends from Bridge Street on the East to the western edge of Hoffman Park on the west, and from Main Street (now Park Avenue) on the south to the Pine River channel on the north.Philo Beers

Mr. Beers, the builder and second keeper of the Cat’s Head lighthouse on the Leelanaw, as well as a U.S. Marshall and a state legislator, moved to Charlevoix with several of his adult children.  The picture at the left is an artist’s depiction of what the original Cat’s Head lighthouse may have looked like.  See the website that talks about that lighthouse and Beers:  http://www.terrypepper.com/lights/michigan/gdtravers/gdtravers.htm.

In 1865 Beers built his homestead [see Charlevoix Sentinel, November 30, 1870], which stands today, and is the oldest surviving building in Charlevoix. You will find it at 103 Park Avenue — home of Roquette Burger Bistro. Mr. Beers conducted business in this location as well. He was one of the first postmasters of Charlevoix (“mail from the South on Tuesdays and Saturdays, from the North on Monday and Friday”), the Probate Judge, and a druggist.  In the 1870 census, Mr. Beers listed his daughter Harriet Beers, his daughter Lennie (Magdalena) Beers Ingalls, and her one-year-old son Almon Ingalls as residents of the house. Almon’s father, also Almon Ingalls, had died one month before little Almon’s birth. Shortly after the census, the baby died as well.

By 1870 Mr. Beers was ill with “rheumatism” and a new postmaster was named. The post office was moved across Bridge Street to the offices of the Charlevoix Sentinel, the new “Republican newspaper” for a “Democratic town”, founded in 1869 by Williard Smith. Beers died in 1872, but his estate wasn’t settled until 1879, perhaps because there wasn’t a new Probate Judge.

An estate sale at the courthouse was attended by a number of eager locals, and block two was subdivided and sold to various pioneers. The only structure on the block at that time was the Philo Beers house. It was sold, along with 1/3 of the block, reaching all the way to the channel, to a Mr. Bartholomew.

Several years later, Bartholomew built a large store with an auditorium on its second story, at the southwest corner of Bridge St. and Main St. The building eventually burned to the ground, but in its heyday the auditorium sat 600 people.

Bartholomew sold the Philo Beers house and the land to Lousia See, wife of Byron See, who had purchased the corner lot at Bridge and Main at Beers’s estate sale.  See built a grocery store on the corner lot, and it burned in 1906. A new building was constructed, and today it houses Truffles Patisserie.

The Sees sold the Beers house and the corner lot to Emma and Geik Geiken.  Geiken was a prominent fisherman and tug boat operator.  Over the years the house has had a number of occupants, both families and businesses, many of whom had interesting stories, which we will relate at a later time.

One use of the building deserves mention, however.  Jane Coleman Stanley (nee Jane Caroline Mahon), notable water colorist, once exhibited her work in the “little house with the yellow doors.”  The doors of the building have been painted yellow again, to honor Stanley.  Her work can be found at the Belvedere Club.  The Historical Society also owns some of her paintings.  A book about her, written and privately published by her daughter, Alice Stanley Acheson, can occasionally be found on eBay.  Ms. Acheson was a painter in her own right, born in Charlevoix, and married to Dean Acheson, President Truman’s Secretary of State.

Researching the History of the Building – PowerPoint

Copyright 2011 by Charlevoix County History Preservation Society.  All rights reserved.

Comment by John B. Ten Eyck, June, 2009:

In regards to Philo Beers: I am a distant cousin through his dau., Lucy A., 1832-1911, who married Robert Carlyle, 1831-1909. Hattie and Lucy travel between frequently between their homes in Rockford, Kent Co., and Charlevoix. It appears that Philo’s wife was one Magdelena Pittenger of New York, hence the last child, born was named Magdelena. Mother “Lena” died giving birth in 1848. Her grave site is unknown, however it was a custom of the times that the burial is most likely on the old homestead in Courtland Twp., Kent Co.,MI
The Carlyle family dates back to the 13th century and before. What is known that one William Carlyle married the younger sister, Margaret, of the Robert Bruce that was made famous in the Mel Gibson movie “Braveheart.”

A comment provided by John B. Ten Eyck, December, 2009:

The history of the Carlyles dates back to the 11th century in Scotland.  They were always “players” in the great battles for Scottish independence, but never played major roles.

The village of Terregles, Kirkcudbrighshire, Scotland, where Robert Carlyle, 1831-1909, the husband of Lucy Ann Beers, 1832-1911, dau. of Philo, was born, temporarily housed Mary Queen of Scots. She was also Queen of France and thus the one of the Carlyle’s Royal connections as the Carlyles are connected to the current Royals of England.

Even today the Scots show polite contempt for British rule, and call Prince Charles, “the Scottish Royal Pretender.”

Thank you for publishing the photos of Philo, which will be sent to Rockford, Mich. Historical Society in my next “Carlyle Biographies” along with the Carlyle research found on my recent trip to Scotland.


5 Comments on “Philo Beers House”

  1. John B. Ten Eyck says:

    Re: Philo Beers and w Magdelena Pittinger
    Cheers and Happy Holidays to All.
    More on Philo and his wife, Magdelena “Lena” Pittinger.
    I found another website on Rootsweb.com that incorrectly, so I believe, has another line confused this Philo’s Beers family. There is no known contributor to verify his/her research.
    Also, I have tried to find the grave site of Madelena Pittinger, 1804-1848, wife of Philo in Courtland Twp., Kent Co., MI., but without success. In those pioneer days, it was not uncommon to bury family on the original land patent. This custom remained until the 1870’s and possibily longer.
    God Bless (in Scottish Gaelic, “Beannachd Leibh”)
    Yours aye,
    John B. Ten Eyck (Carlyle of Clan Bruce)

    From Raechel: Yes, you are correct. Philo Beers was a common name at the time, and there is one who lived in Illinois at the same time. He worked a bit for Abraham Lincoln, I believe. Anyway, that is not our Philo Beers, although someone has confused the two on RootsWeb. Do you have a copy of the land patent in Kent by any chance? I’ll trade you two of Lucy’s for Philo’s.
    Have a great holiday.

  2. This is one of the pleasant surprises of browsing/surfing or whatever you want to call it. You can easily find something that matters or at least entertains.
    I want you to know that I appreciate this.

  3. Christine Bryant says:

    I am a descendant of the Beers name and trying to find out how I am related to Philo. Does anyone know Philo’s parents’ names.

    • Rae says:

      Hi, Christine.

      Philo was born in Connecticut. State borders were in flux then, and sometimes his birthplace was listed as New York. Be careful with your research — there were lots of guys named Philo Beers in that area.

      A couple of Philo’s descendants through his son Ammon showed me a book they have that traces his ancestors back through the early 1500s. I wrote down a few of the generations, so here they are:

      Philo’s parents: Ammon Beers and Lucy Sherman (Scotland, 1773-1841 Kent)
      Ammon’s parents: David Beers (1752-1825) and Hannah Griffin (1755 –1823)
      David’s parents: Daniel Beers (1714 – 1800) and Mabel Booth (1722 – 1816)
      Daniel’s parents: Samuel Beers and Sarah Sherman
      Mabel’s parents: Jonathan Booth and Hester Galpin

      I believe Philo had only one sibling, and that sibling seems to have passed away, so you would have to go back another generation for a common ancestor unless you are descended from Philo. Are you? He and his wife Magdalena (Pittinger) had 9 children, I believe. Here they are:

      George, born in 1829
      Henry, born in 1830 in NY
      Lucy, born in 1833
      Sarah, born in 1834
      Charles Gaylord, born in 1835
      Cyrus Hobert, born in 1839
      Ammon, born in 1841 in Courtland, Kent County, MI
      Harriet, born in 1845 in Courtland, Kent County, MI
      Magdalena, born in 1848

      I’ve been told that Sarah, Charles Gaylord, and Cyrus Hobert, whose names come from the family Bible, moved in with other families upon the death of Magdalena Pittinger in 1848, probably when she gave birth to her daughter Magdalena. There is pretty good census information tracking the movements and descendants of the other children.

      Hope that all helps.

  4. Pat Bailey says:

    What a wonderful website.
    Philo Beers is my husband’s 3rd g. grandfather. I would be very interested in learning more about the “book” that traces the Beers ancestors back to the 1500’s.

    Can you share more information about this book?

    We live in Washington DC and have spent summers visiting/staying in Petoskey, Michigan.

    Thanks Pat


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s